Note: This column is available free to the public. If you like my writings on genre issues, consider backing my Patreon. Also TW because this column includes a ton of coverage of racism and sexual harassment.
Harassment allegations against multiple genre authors
Over the last week several prominent genre authors have been accused of sexual harassment. First, Paul Krueger was accused of harassing numerous women in the publishing industry. Suzanne Walker wrote a thread about what happened to her, as did Alyssa Wong, and Wendy Xu. Krueger eventually wrote a unspecific apology before deleting his Twitter account.
In response to the allegations Krueger’s literary agent DongWon Song wrote about the situation and later announced he was ending his relationship with Krueger.
The second author was Myke Cole, who apologized after Cara McGee described what Cole did to her. Cole blamed being drunk but, as was pointed out, that doesn’t negate the harm done. In addition, Alexandra Erin and others questioned the apology, especially since Cole made a similar apology in 2018 over different allegations. Even Cole said he was “reiterating my 2018 apology here as it’s still germane.” (Update: Kate Welch has also written a disturbing thread on Cole's actions.)
A number of people have spoken out about the different treatment of Krueger, who is a person of color, and Cole, who is a white man. Krueger lost his agent and was generally shunned, while the same treatment has so far not happened to Cole. (Update: Cole's agent Joshua Bilmes says they have now "parted ways." while Angry Robot says they will publish no new books by Cole.)
“Hit piece” attacks Rebecca Roanhorse as Native writers defend her
Award-winning author Rebecca Roanhorse wrote the other day that a Native journalist was going to publish a piece questioning her "authenticity" as a Native writer. The story came out yesterday on Indianz(dot)com and called Roanhorse the “Elizabeth Warren of the sci-fi set.” I’m not linking to the article because it is extremely poor journalism and contains serious errors.
A number of Native writers have come to Roanhorse’s defense. Robert Jago described the article as a "hit piece" filled with errors of fact and logic. Other must-read comments from Native writers include these Tweets and threads from Erika T. Wurth, Turquoise Day, Kiros Auld, and Kevin Brown. In addition, Rebekah Weatherspoon ties this attack article in with anti-Blackness, as does Kayla Shaggy in an excellent essay on anti-Blackness within Indigenous circles and how it relates to the treatment of Roanhorse.
Roanhorse, whose mother is Native American, also identifies as Black and has previously been attacked by a small group of Native writers and critics who imply she isn't truly Native because she was given up for adoption as a child. These attacks have been led by Dr. Debbie Reese, the founder and editor of American Indians in Children’s Literature.
As Mercedes Acosta writes, Reese "mentored Rebecca Roanhorse. By all accounts (except hers now teehee) didn't have an issue w what Rebecca wrote til she published and got successful (as she deserves) then suddenly Deb and crew turned into detectives and started perpetuating lies Roanhorse has since addressed."
It’s worth noting that on June 2, which was Blackout Tuesday on social media, Reese posted a Twitter thread attacking Roanhorse. In the thread Reese wrote "Rebecca knows how much I did for her. If I was anti-Black, I would have not have done any of that."
However, a large number of authors responded by pointing out the serious racial issues with Reese’s thread and especially around writing it on Blackout Tuesday. Reese eventually deleted the thread. As Karen Strong wrote in response to Reese’s thread, "I've been watching you and I see a pattern. Why are you so obsessed with Rebecca Roanhorse? Is your new agenda to ruin her? I see the anti-Blackness in you.”
Ebony Elizabeth Thomas, who considered herself a friend of Reese, responded to the thread by writing an in-depth essay about the attacks on Roanhorse and how much of children's literature criticism is anti-Black. She also resigned as a board member of the Children’s Literature Association.
Other News and Info
- Harassment and racism allegations have also been raised against young adult authors Taylor Barton/Brooklyn Ray and Kaelan Rhywiol. Charlie Knight discusses the issues around Rhywiol while Emery Lee covers the issues around Taylor Barton (who also writes under the pen name Brooklyn Ray). Other relevant comments include threads by Tash McAdam, Claribel A. Ortega, and Ray Stoeve. In response NineStar Press removed books by both authors. Taylor Barton eventually deleted their Twitter account, as did Kaelan Rhywiol.
- The comics industry has also seen a flurry of harassment allegations. Yesterday Shawna Gore said she was “assaulted, harassed, and retaliated against by Scott Allie” of Dark Horse Comics. Cameron Stewart and Warren Ellis have also been accused of predatory behavior while multiple people have likewise accused Jason Latour of harassment. Finally, Charles Brownstein resigned as the executive director of the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund because of a sexual assault from 2005. In response to all this, former Batman writer Tom King started the ComicsPledge against abuse, harassment, grooming, and manipulation.
- Foz Meadows explains why sexually loaded jokes or comments at conventions and elsewhere count as a form harassment.
- Catherynne M. Valente wrote two must-read threads on harassment issues in the genre. As she said, “Conventions & convention bars are professional networking spaces for writers & artists By sexualizing that space, you’re taking opportunities away from people who could be spending time with someone who values their work & not the use of their bodies for your temporary amusement.”
- In response to genre harassment issues, people are also discussing the need to change the barcon culture, in particular by creating “more networking spaces that don't involve alcohol.”
- Barnes & Noble has laid off many of their book buyers. Layoffs include SF/F and graphic novel buyer James Killen, who had been with B&N for 41 years.
- After the Internet Archive closed its Temporary National Emergency Library in response to a lawsuit brought by publishers, a number of "digital radicals" attacked Chuck Wendig, blaming him for the closure. As Wendig wrote, “I am not for destroying the Internet Archive … I have not advocated for that, nor am I involved in any lawsuit that would have that effect. It's not well-off-white-guys who get hurt by non-compensation, btw -- we usually do okay. It's everybody else.” Wendig later locked his Twitter account because of attacks and threats. Other good comments on all this from Silvia Moreno-Garcia, Nick Mamatas, and N. K. Jemisin.
- Justina Ireland warns that “if you are a Sensitivity Reader and you are approached by Quiethouse Editing, please do NOT sign a contract with them. Those rate are terrible.” Ireland adds more details here.
- Vox covers the ugly history of racism in the romance genre, and how things are finally changing.
- Karen Lord has a very good thread on literary agents and others in publishing opening their DMs to pitches from Black creatives.
- George R.R. Martin says he's making steady progress on The Winds of Winter but added “It’s going to be a huge book, and I still have a long way to go.”
- The GoFundMe to help Uncle Hugo’s Bookstore has raised nearly $150,000 of their half-million goal.
- Clarkesworld shares charts showing the magazine’s submissions by genre and their international submissions by year since 2008
- Excellent and moving essay by Brandon Taylor on managing private anxiety in a very public pandemic.
- The Clarke Award shortlist has been released.
- Hillary Monahan shares screen-shots discussing racial issues around horror publisher Tell-Tale Press, owned and operated by Andrea Dawn.
- Progress: We finally have a female Orson Scott Card.
- Locus is looking for new reviewers and strongly encourages Black and Indigenous applicants, as well as people from other marginalized communities. Details>>
- The RWA is offering scholarships for their upcoming virtual conference. Details>>
- If There's Anyone Left is searching for flash speculative fiction from marginalized members of the sci-fi/spec community. Details>>