Every year the Two Guys with PhDs use the final two episodes of the year as a respective, a look back at some of the best comics out there. Next week they’ll release their own favorites of the past twelve months, but for this, their penultimate show of the year, Andy and Derek discuss what others consider outstanding. The 2016 volume Best American Comics, edited by cartoonist Roz Chast (and with series editor Bill Kartalopoulos), includes thirty contributions from a variety of creators and displaying a wide range of styles and storytelling strategies. These comics were originally published between September 1, 2015 and August 31, 2015, and in many cases they include titles that the guys have discussed on past episodes. (For insights into the selection process for this volume, check out the previously published interview with Bill Kartalopoulos.)
As the guys point out, there are entries in this collection that should come as no surprise to comics readers — e.g., Adrian Tomine’s “Killing and Dying,” Drew Friedman’s “R. Crumb and Me,” various Kate Beaton strips, and excerpts from Richard McGuire’s Here and Chris Ware’s The Last Saturday — but some of the most notable contributions are from artists with whom the guys weren’t yet familiar, or are selections that might not be on most readers’ “Best of” lists. As you’ll hear on this episode, Derek and Andy are excited to discover the work of Taylor-Ruth Baldwin, Sophia Zdon, Lance Ward, and Char Esmé, while at the same time they are glad to see recognition of works by Joe Ollmann, John Porcellino, Keiler Roberts, and Nina Bunjevac. But every piece in this anthology is worthy of attention, as are the various titles listed in its “Notable Comics” section at the very end. With a new year on the horizon, it’s always useful to look back at those comics that have helped define where we are today. And as the guys point out, the annual Best American Comics volumes are some of the gauges out there.