Writing Selfie and Thoughts on the Amount of Detail We Ask Readers to Keep in Their Minds
 
My Patreon supporters will get their Thursday chapter later today, but I wanted to share this idea because I just had it and I think it's so important.

(If you want to tell me that everyone else has already thought of this, fine. But I swear that I would have read it somewhere if that were the case.)


So. I'm writing this chapter about Natalie's first day at her internship, because this is the part of the story where Natalie and Meredith's journeys start to separate; they're sisters, they've grown up in the same environment, and now they're getting these different experiences as young adults and that'll start shaping how they view the adult world. (Also how much money they'll make, but we'll get to that.)


Meredith lives in her head much more than Natalie does, so her chapters are always denser because she's always internally monologuing about everything. 


But this Natalie chapter felt really surfacy, like I was just skimming over the top of the story. "This feels like a particular kind of writing," I internally monologued to myself. "Like a chick-lit beach read that goes by really quickly."


And then I thought of how little detail I was including. 


I was providing enough detail to give readers a sense of place: "Natalie had rolled a cardigan inside her tote; she pulled it out as she followed Mike MacAllister into the rows of cubicles." So we know we're in an office and we know it's air-conditioned and we know that Natalie has a cardigan and a tote bag (not a purse). 


But those are all of the details I ask readers to carry in their heads. They can picture the rest of the office as they read, but they don't have to do the work of making their picture match up with the text. 


Compare it to this Meredith chapter: "The water looked blue from above but looked like nothing once you were inside, the same way it felt cold when Meredith first put her feet in and then stopped feeling cold once Alex laughed and said she had to put her whole head under the water, and then counted to three so she would do it. The swimsuit was a little too big, and Meredith kept one hand busy pulling it away from her stomach, feeling it slowly detach from her skin and make a floating balloon as the water came in to fill the gap."


That's a lot more detail. I could have written "The water felt cold when Meredith first stepped into the pool. Alex laughed and told her she had to put her head under. "I'll count to three!" When Meredith's head came out of the water, the water didn't feel cold anymore. It felt like nothing at all."


You still have the basic parts of the scene and you can still mentally picture all of it, but you're using your own detail instead of the detail I provide. 


I'm pretty sure it's harder to read something that asks you to carry more detail from scene to scene, because you have to put all of that detail somewhere and recall it as you go. At least, that's what I'm theorizing at this point, when I'm asking myself "why does this chapter feel like a beach read?" 


I've also made myself a lot of notes to add detail back into the books, especially sensory detail—and I've been taking these notes since the beginning, I didn't just start taking them now—because I know that when I write in a hurry, the detail is often the first thing to go. (I occasionally write in a hurry. Whose idea was it to give you two chapters a week?)


Because so many of the books I love are so richly detailed, and because I do know how to write it, and because I don't want to forget to write it, before I get to the final draft.


Anyway, that is what I am thinking about right now. 


Am I thinking about something that everybody already knows, or had you also never thought of this before?

Tier Benefits
Pledge $0 or more per creation
patrons
Everyone
Pledge $0.01 or more per creation
patrons
Patrons Only
Pledge $1 or more per creation
38 patrons
At this level, you get access to all the chapters of The Biographies of Ordinary People. New chapters will arrive via email and old chapters will live in the Patreon interface so you can read 'em whenever you want.

You also get access to the Spotify playlist where I post all of the music I reference in the story—everything from Mozart to Webern to Technotronic. 

You also get my thanks. Because I couldn't do this without you.
Pledge $10 or more per creation
6 patrons
At this level, you get access to the monthly advice column. Every month, I'll answer one or two questions from Patreon supporters, and I'll give you the same honesty I brought to Advice for the Anxious or any of my other personal writing.

You also get chapters, the Spotify playlist, and my thanks. I've run two advice columns for other publications (Ask a Freelancer and Pitch Fix) and I think this Patreon advice column will be really interesting for all of us.
Pledge $20 or more per creation
5 patrons
At the $20 pledge, you get a separate copy of The Biographies of Ordinary People with my annotations. If you are interested in the craft of writing, or in the idea of how we use personal memories to fill out narratives about fictional people—or if you just want a peek into my brain—sign up for this level.

You also get chapters, the Spotify playlist, the monthly advice column, and my thanks. Because you are supportive, and because I am excited to share my thoughts and feelings about this process with you.
Pledge $40 or more per creation
1 patron
I compared this to a PBS pledge drive, so let's make it legit: at the $40.00 or more pledge level, you get a coffee mug featuring the quote "she made a home of words and will." Perfect for fans of hot beverages and iambic tetrameter!

You also get the monthly advice column, all the annotations, the Spotify playlist, and the chapters.

You also get my thanks. Because I know you aren't really in this for the coffee mug; you're in this to help me share this story with readers. And I am very thankful for that.
Recent Posts